This post was originally published on this site
Nestled at the foot of Egypt’s Holy and God-Trodden Mount Sinai, the Sacred Autonomous Royal Monastery of Saint Catherine is the world’s oldest continuously inhabited Christian monastery. Today, this sacred monastery is facing legal, diplomatic, economic, and cultural challenges which speak to broader 21st-century issues of heritage, sovereignty, and development.
The monastery was founded between 548 and 565 CE by order of the Byzantine Emperor Justinian I. It stands on the very ground where the Prophet Moses is believed to have encountered the Burning Bush, as recorded in Exodus 3:2-5:
“There the angel of the Lord appeared to him in flames of fire from within a bush. Moses saw that though the bush was on fire it did not burn up…‘Do not come any closer,’ God said. ‘Take off your sandals, for the place where you are standing is holy ground.’”
Governed by the autonomous Orthodox Church of Mount Sinai and linked canonically to the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem, Saint Catherine’s Monastery received its name after the relics of St. Catherine of Alexandria were found in a cave near the monastery. In 2002 the monastery was designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site for its spiritual, historical, and cultural importance.
Egypt’s 2025 ruling
In May 2025, the Egyptian Ismailia Administrative Appeal Court issued a ruling declaring the land on which Saint Catherine’s Monastery sits, as well as certain surrounding areas, constitutes state property.
While the court affirmed the monks retain the right to use the monastery and religious sites, it did not recognize the monastic community’s private ownership of the land. Prior to this court ruling, the monastery’s property status was understood to rest on endowment, continuous possession, and state recognition. This understanding had lasted throughout Byzantine, Islamic, Ottoman, and Egyptian sovereignty.
The 2025 ruling raised serious concerns within the Greek Orthodox Church and among Orthodox faithful globally. Church leaders and community members warned this reclassification could threaten the monastery’s autonomy and ability to sustain its traditional way of life.
In particular, the dispute roused the engagement of the Hellenic Republic and Orthodox ecclesiastical authorities since Saint Catherine’s Monastery’s administration is tied to the wider Greek Orthodox Church–though granted autonomy over its own community, the monastery is under the canonical jurisdiction of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem. Greek officials united in expressing concern the court’s ruling could endanger the community’s sustainability and spiritual independence.
In response, Egyptian officials, including the foreign ministry and presidential office, affirmed their commitment to preserving the site’s historic and spiritual character, stating the ruling would not affect the monastery’s function as a place of worship.
Athens and Cairo began diplomatic discussions to clarify the monastery’s legal status and protect the monastery’s religious, sacred character. In late 2025, Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis announced Cairo and Athens had reached an agreement to seek formal protections for Saint Catherine’s Monastery and ensure neither the monastery nor its places of worship could be converted from their religious function. The full details of the agreement have not been made publicly available.
Implications of the “Great Transfiguration Project”
Parallel to the legal dispute, the Egyptian government had been advancing a large-scale initiative known as the “Great Transfiguration Project,” which envisions transforming Mount Sinai and Saint Catherine’s Monastery into a premier spiritual and cultural tourism center. The initiative calls for the construction of new roads, hotels, eco-lodges, museums, and commercial facilities designed to attract international visitors.
Proponents of the Great Transfiguration Project argue it would create jobs, boost the local economy, and showcase Egypt’s religious heritage. Critics, however, have raised concerns that such development risks reducing a living monastic community to a “spiritual theme park,” subordinating centuries of liturgical life to the modern-day demands of mass tourism.
The local Bedouin tribes–known as Jebeliya or Gebeliah–who have maintained a unique, integral relationship with the monastery since the time of Emperor Justinian I have also raised concerns about their potential displacement, the loss of agricultural land, and their exclusion or marginalization in decision-making processes.
According to the local tradition, the Bedouin are descendants of the military families stationed by Emperor Justinian I to protect the monks from nomadic raiders. Although the Bedouin tribes later converted to Islam, they retain distinct cultural ties to Saint Catherine’s Monastery, and for centuries have worked as guards, laborers, craftsmen, and mediators for the monks.
The monastery’s relationship with the Bedouin has been central to its economic self-sufficiency. Saint Catherine’s Monastery has historically sustained itself through its lands and hospitality to pilgrims, and the Bedouin have in turn provided labor, protection, and agricultural assistance. A legal reclassification of monastic lands, combined with overwhelming touristic development, would place this careful balance and self-sufficiency under severe strain.
Different faiths, shared heritage
Saint Catherine’s Monastery has long stood as a remarkable testament to interfaith coexistence. Its compound includes a historic mosque dating to the Fatimid period (1106 AD), and the monastery is considered a sacred site across the Abrahamic traditions.
According to the monastic tradition, in 628 CE, the Prophet Muhammad issued a written covenant, known as the Achtiname or Ashtiname, granting formal protection to the monks of Saint Catherine’s Monastery.
The covenant, which includes a handprint seal traditionally attributed to the Prophet Muhammad, reads as follows:
“This is a message from Muhammad ibn Abdullah, as a covenant to those who adopt Christianity … I hold out against anything that displeases them … No compulsion is to be on them. Neither are their judges to be removed from their jobs nor their monks from their monasteries. No one is to destroy a house of their religion, to damage it, or to carry anything from it to the Muslims’ houses … They are my allies and have my secure charter against all that they hate.”
This prophetic legacy speaks directly to Egypt’s own religious and civilizational heritage–a heritage Egypt can uplift by safeguarding Saint Catherine’s Monastery as today’s legal and diplomatic debate unfolds. In the shifting terrain of law, development, and diplomacy, the monastery endures as a symbol that shared sacred history can create a future of protection, dignity, and coexistence across faiths and peoples.
The Orthodox community worldwide continues to pray for a just and lasting resolution—one that honors the monastery’s sacred mission, preserves the livelihoods and dignity of the Bedouin who share its life, and ensures that its holy ground remains, as it has for fifteen centuries, a place set apart for prayer, pilgrimage, and the living witness of the Christian faith.
Giselle Soares is an Orthodox Christian currently serving as an Ambassador Warren Clark Fellow for Churches for Middle East Peace (CMEP).
The post Opinion | We must protect Saint Catherine’s Monastery appeared first on Orthodox Observer.
